‹ CHAPTER 17, ALL LESSONS

MASTER · CHAPTER 17 · LESSON 3 OF 5

Attacks & assumptions

The security budget

When the subsidy fades, who will pay for security? 5 min

Miners spend on hardware and energy roughly what mining pays them. That total, subsidy plus fees, is often called the security budget: the more it is worth, the more an attack costs.

The open question

The subsidy halves every four years. Today it is still the larger part of a miner's income in most blocks. Eventually fees must carry security on their own. Will fees be enough?

  • Optimistic view: as Bitcoin becomes more valuable and widely used, demand for block space and its price rise.
  • Worried view: if fees stay low, the security budget shrinks, and attacks become cheaper relative to the value secured.
  • Middle view: the answer depends on adoption over decades, and the subsidy still has a long tail before it becomes negligible.

Changing the supply schedule to fix it is widely rejected, because the fixed supply is one of Bitcoin's core promises.

▶ SEE IT IN THE MACHINE

The HALVING ruler shows the subsidy shrinking step by step; fees are what must fill the gap.

What to remember

  • Security budget = subsidy + fees paid to miners.
  • The subsidy halves every four years.
  • Whether fees will suffice is debated.

Quick check

What does the security budget measure?

Why is raising the supply not seen as an acceptable fix?